Ian Quayle discusses a case about the enforceability of restrictive covenants. The claimants sought to declare that a 1977 restrictive covenant did not bind their land because the purchaser under that conveyance did not own the land intended to benefit from the...
Restrictive Covenants
This section of the site contains information on various matters relating to restrictive covenants:
- Benefit of covenants – Has the person who wants to enforce the covenant got the benefit of it?
- Burden – Is the person who wants to carry out the development subject to the burden of the covenant?
- Consent to development – Can the person with the benefit unreasonably withhold consent?
- Enforcing covenants – Injunction or damages in lieu?
- Interpretation of covenants – a case on the meaning of “a private dwelling house”.
- Modification of restrictive covenants under s84 of the 1925 Act to allow the development to proceed – when will this happen, what do you need to establish, how is compensation assessed, what is the procedure?
- Variation under s610 of the Housing Act 1985 to allow conversion from one large house to a number of smaller dwellings – a procedure often overlooked.
To select the topic of interest to you click on the list on the lift.
To use the The Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) website to search for decisions in restrictive covenant cases (or indeed any other case) click here. For the enforcement of positive covenants click here.
Legal Dispute Over Tomlin Order Implementation
Emma Preece and Emma Humphries examine a legal dispute regarding the application for directions on implementing a Tomlin Order related to structural changes and alterations to the external appearance of a property. Case name, reference and Bailii link Rutland...
Modification of Restrictive Covenants
Ian Quayle considers another case before the Upper Tribunal where consideration was given as to whether an application to modify a restrictive covenant under S85(1)(aa) LPA 1925 was considered. The unusual feature of the case was that the applicant provided the Upper...
Restrictive Covenants and Their Impact on Development
Joanna Morrish examines the case of Medley v Mackenzie & Ors [2024], which involves the modification and discharge of restrictive covenants under Section 84 of the Law of Property Act 1925. Case name, reference and Bailii link Medley v Mackenzie & Ors...
Restrictive Covenants – Agricultural Covenants
Discharge of a restrictive covenant under section 84 of the Law of Property Act 1925 limiting use of land to agricultural purposes. Emma Preece and Emma Humphries discuss the case of Robertson v Pace [2024] UKUT 123 (LC) (20 May 2024), which concerns the discharge of...
Contract Interpretation in Restrictive Covenant Modifications
Tanfield Chambers discuss the recent decision in Mackenzie v Cheung & Anor [2024] where Barristers Carl Fain and Richard Miller, instructed by Jonathan Warner-Reed of Davitt Jones Bould, acted for the successful Respondent in a Court of Appeal case concerning the...
Modification or Discharge of a Restrictive Covenant
Emma Preece and Emma Humphreys consider the case of Rogers & Anor v Dinshaw & Ors and the modification or discharge of a covenant under Section 84(1) of the Law of Property Act 1925 to retrospectively allow the retention of two property extensions carried out...
Breaching a Covenant in Real Estate Developments
Robert Kelly discusses the recent case of Fosse Urban Projects Ltd v Whyte & Ors [2023] where another cynical breach by a developer was punished by the Upper Tribunal. Case Name and Bailii Link: Fosse Urban Projects Ltd v Whyte & Ors [2023] UKUT 286 (LC)...
Section 84 of the Law of Property Act 1925
Emma Preece and Emma Humphries discuss the case of Blackhorse Investments (Borough) Limited v The London Borough of Southwark in relation to an application to set aside order/Tribunal jurisdiction. Case name & Bailii Link: Blackhorse Investments (Borough)...
Restrictive Covenants and General Release Provisions in Conveyances
Ian Quayle discusses an interesting case concerning the enforceability of restrictive covenants in the context of the interpretation of a general release provision in a conveyance. Case name, reference and Bailii link Mackenzie v Cheung & Anor [2024] EWCA Civ...